Gem City Pizza

Gem City Pizza Menu

111 Reviews
Pizza restaurant
Closed

About the Menu

Gem City Pizza offers a straightforward, casual menu centered around classic and specialty pizzas paired with a selection of hearty sides and satisfying salads. The menu invites you to enjoy comforting, well-loved flavors ideal for relaxed gatherings, whether it’s a family dinner, a weekend party, or a casual night out with friends.

Among the diverse offerings, you’ll find standout items like their signature Buffalo Chicken Sub, hearty salads such as the C B R Salad or Steak Salad, and a variety of rolls and cheesy stix perfect for sharing. Their pizza options range from traditional 12” and 16” pies with a choice of toppings, to larger party trays designed to feed a group, making it easy to tailor your order to any occasion.

The food pairs naturally with the inviting, down-to-earth atmosphere of the place, encouraging moments of simple enjoyment and connection over good pizza and familiar sides. Whether stopping in for a quick bite or bringing friends together to share multiple trays, Gem City Pizza’s menu feels approachable and satisfying without fuss.

Gem City Pizza Menu - 1
Gem City Pizza Menu - 2
Gem City Pizza Menu - 3
Gem City Pizza Menu - 4
Gem City Pizza Menu - 5

Business Menu

SALADS
Garden Salad
US$4.50
Antipasto Salad
US$7.00
Buffalo Chicken Salad
US$7.00
Chicken Salad
US$7.00
C.B.R. Salad
US$7.00
Steak Salad
US$7.00
SIDES
CHEESE ROLL
US$2.50
RONI ROLL
US$3.50
SWEET N' SPICY ROLL
US$4.00
SPECIALTY ROLL
US$4.50
MEATBALL DUMPLING
US$4.00
STIX W/CHEESE
US$5.75
SWEET N' SPICY STIX
US$6.75
STIX W/1 Topping
US$7.75
PIZZA
12" Round Pizza (2 toppings max) - Reg
US$12.00
12" Round Pizza (2 toppings max) - Specialty
US$14.00
12" Round Pizza (2 toppings max) - Meat
US$15.00
16" Round Thin Crust (2 toppings) - Reg
US$13.00
16" Round Thin Crust (2 toppings) - Specialty
US$15.00
16" Round Thin Crust (2 toppings) - Meat
US$17.00
Party Tray - 28 Slices
US$33.00
Specialty trays - BBQ Chicken Pizza
US$20.00
Specialty trays - Buffalo Chicken Pizza
US$20.00
Specialty trays - B.L.T. Pizza
US$20.00
Specialty trays - C.B.R. Pizza
US$20.00
Specialty trays - White Pizza
US$20.00
Specialty trays - Meat Pizza
US$22.00
12" Gluten Free Pizza
US$13.00
Mini Specialty Tray
US$12.00
Meat Specialty Tray
US$13.00
Subs
BBQ Chicken Sub
US$6.50
Buffalo Chicken Sub
US$6.50
C.B.R. Sub
US$6.50
Chicken Parm Sub
US$6.50
Italian Sub
US$6.50
Meatball Sub
US$6.50
Philly Steak Sub
US$6.50
Calzones
Zone
US$10.00
BBQ Chicken Zone
US$12.00
Buffalo Chicken Zone
US$12.00
C.B.R. Zone
US$12.00
Chicken Parm Zone
US$12.00
Italian Zone
US$12.00
Meatball Zone
US$12.00
Philly Steak Zone
US$12.00
Meat Zone
US$14.00
Sauces
Red
US$0.50
Garlic
US$0.50
Swagger Sauce - Cup
US$0.50
Swagger Sauce - Jar
US$8.00
Beverages
Bottled Water
US$1.00
Soda 12oz Can - Pepsi
US$1.25
Soda 12oz Can - Mt Dew
US$1.25
Soda 12oz Can - Diet MT Dew
US$1.25
Soda 12oz Can - Mt Dew Blast
US$1.25
Soda 12oz Can - Coke
US$1.25
Soda 12oz Can - Diet Coke
US$1.25
Soda 12oz Can - Sprite
US$1.25
Soda 12oz Can - Dr Pepper
US$1.25
Soda 12oz Can - Nestle Iced Tea w/Lemon
US$1.25
Specials
Holy Boli
US$30.00
Mini Holy Boli
US$15.00
1st Tray
US$17.00
2nd Tray
US$16.00
City Boyz BBQ
US$22.00